Returns

Returns Policy

Eligibility, return timing, and the situations that are not returnable.

Eligible ready-to-ship returns are accepted within 30 days of delivery.

Prepaid, insured FedEx return labels are provided for eligible returns.

Custom, made-to-order, resized, altered, and final-sale items are not returnable.

Eligible returns

Returns are accepted within 30 days of delivery on ready-to-ship items that are unaltered and in original condition.

  • Eligible returns receive a prepaid, insured FedEx return label.
  • Engraved ready-to-ship rings are subject to a $75 non-refundable restocking fee.
  • Missing GIA or IGI certificates, or missing branded packaging, incur a $100 fee.

Items that are not returnable

  • Custom pieces.
  • Made-to-order pieces.
  • Resized or altered items.
  • Anything marked final sale.

How to start a return

Email Fifth Alloy with your order number and return request, and the next steps will be confirmed from there.